⚡ Quick Verdict
A high handicapper using a Titleist Pro V1 is paying $55 per dozen for performance they cannot access — and in many cases, losing distance compared to a ball that matches their swing speed. This is not a knock on the Pro V1. It is a data point. Here is what high handicappers should actually be using, and why.
⚖️ This page contains affiliate links — we earn a small commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. Editorial Policy →
Callaway Supersoft
- Ultra-low 38 compression — softest Callaway ball
- HEX Aerodynamics for consistently straight flight
- Best choice for swing speeds under 80mph
Prices change — click to see current price
Srixon Soft Feel
- Low-compression — benefits slower swing speeds most
- Soft ionomer cover for better feel around greens
- Under $28/dozen — best value two-piece available
Prices change — click to see current price
| Golf Ball | Compression | Best For | Price/Dozen | Swing Speed | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Callaway Supersoft | Best distance | ~$25 | 38 | Under 80 mph | ~$25/dozen → |
| Srixon Soft Feel BEST PICK | Best overall | ~$27 | 60 | Under 88 mph | ~$27/dozen → |
| Titleist Velocity | Best step-up | ~$32 | 65 | 75–88 mph | Check price → |
Short Answer: The Srixon Soft Feel at $27
If you carry a handicap above 18 and you want a one-word answer: Srixon Soft Feel. Low compression (60), durable ionomer cover, consistent distance on mis-hits, $27 per dozen. At a high handicap, you are losing 2-3 balls per round — the Srixon lets you lose them without calculating the cost. More importantly, the low compression matches most swing speeds in the 70-85 mph range, which is where most high handicappers sit.
Why the Pro V1 Is Wrong for Most High Handicappers
The Titleist Pro V1 is a 90-compression ball designed for swing speeds above 90 mph. If you are swinging below that, you are not compressing it fully at impact, which means you are losing distance compared to a properly matched lower-compression ball. A 2022 study by MyGolfSpy found that lower-compression balls were faster off the driver for swing speeds in the low-80s range. The Pro V1 at 90 compression underperformed a 60-70 compression ball by 3-5 yards carry distance for golfers below 88 mph swing speed. Additionally, at $55/dozen, a golfer who loses 2 balls per round is spending $10+ per lost ball. The Srixon Soft Feel at $27/dozen makes each lost ball a $2.25 event rather than a $4.58 event. The financial pressure changes how you play — you will attempt hero shots out of water hazards to recover a Pro V1 that you would not even think about with a Srixon.
Best Overall: Srixon Soft Feel
BEST OVERALLCompression 60, $27/dozen. The right ball for swing speeds under 88 mph — which covers most golfers carrying an 18+ handicap. Consistent distance on off-centre hits, durable enough to survive cart paths, and $27/dozen means you play without financial anxiety about hazards.
Pros
- Compression 60 — right for under-88 mph swing speeds
- $27/dozen — lowest price for real performance
- Durable ionomer cover outlasts cheaper balls
Cons
- Less greenside spin than urethane balls — expected at this price
- Not ideal above 90 mph swing speed
⚖️ Affiliate link — we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Prices change frequently — click to see the current price.
Best for Distance: Callaway Supersoft
BEST DISTANCECompression 38, $25/dozen. If you swing below 80 mph — common for senior golfers and many female golfers — the Callaway Supersoft is the more aggressive choice. At compression 38, it deforms more readily at impact, which means better energy transfer at lower swing speeds. It will not match the Srixon Soft Feel around the greens, but it will out-drive it for slower swingers.
Pros
- 38 compression — optimal for under-80 mph swing speeds
- $25/dozen — the cheapest quality ball on the market
- Straight flight — low spin off driver reduces hooks and slices
Cons
- Too soft for 90+ mph swing speeds — loses distance at higher speeds
- Less feel than Srixon around the greens
⚖️ Affiliate link — we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Prices change frequently — click to see the current price.
Best Step-Up: Titleist Velocity
BEST STEP-UPCompression 65, $32/dozen. When you are consistently shooting under 95 and your contact is becoming more reliable, the Titleist Velocity is the upgrade from the Srixon Soft Feel. Slightly higher compression, designed specifically for distance — it flies higher and further off the driver while remaining within the right compression range for most high handicappers improving toward mid-handicap territory.
Pros
- Titleist quality at $32/dozen — significantly less than Pro V1
- Designed for distance — higher flight than Srixon Soft Feel
- Good choice as you approach the 15-18 handicap range
Cons
- Less feel than urethane balls around the greens
- Not a significant upgrade over Srixon Soft Feel for pure 18+ handicappers
⚖️ Affiliate link — we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Prices change frequently — click to see the current price.
What to Stop Buying: Random Lake Balls
The argument for lake balls — they are cheap, you find them, why not — makes financial sense but loses the consistency argument. Mixed brands, mixed compressions, unknown number of rounds played, potential damage to covers: every round you play with a different ball is a round where you cannot build reliable distance knowledge. The Srixon Soft Feel at $27/dozen is cheap enough that the consistency benefit over random lake balls is worth the $27.
Frequently Asked Questions
What golf ball should an 18 handicapper use?
Does it matter what golf ball a high handicapper uses?
Should a 20 handicapper use Pro V1?
What is the best cheap golf ball for beginners?
Related Guides
Get the Free Golf Gear Buying Guide
The cheat sheet every weekend golfer needs before buying anything new. No spam, ever.
Browse All Guides →